The In-Laws (1979)

Family tends to be a bit peculiar, especially when it comes to those who enter our lives as a result of marriage. If you pick up just about any joke book written in the last century, there will undoubtedly be an abundance of lighthearted insults and quips directed at one particular group: the in-laws, a term that has come to have a layered meaning as a result of decades of discourse around the supposed discomfort and awkwardness that comes when marrying into an entirely new family, and in the process adopting a set of unintended relatives that suddenly become a part of your life. In reality, most people are perfectly happy with their in-laws, who tend to be relatively ordinary people. However, there’s very little fun in this, which is precisely what motivated Andrew Bergman to conceive of the film that would eventually become The In-Laws, a bitingly funny satire brought to life by journeyman filmmaker Arthur Hiller, who manages to craft one of the most subversive and unconventional comedies of the 1970s, which was arguably a time when American humour was at its peak, particularly in terms of lampooning everyday culture. The premise is simple – Sheldon Kornpett is a mild-mannered dentist living a comfortable life in New Jersey, while Vince Ricardo is a loose-cannon CIA agent who spends more time hobnobbing with dictators and assassins than he does with his own family. The two men do not know each other, but this is only temporary, as they are about to become relatives, since their children are set to be married in only a few days. The clash of personalities proves to be only the start of the tense relationship between the pair, especially when Sheldon is inadvertently thrust into Vince’s world after the latter forces him to participate in a scheme that involves forgery, fascism and even a bit of murder for good measure, leading them from the suburbs of the United States to the jungles of a fictional South American country, which could very well end up being their final resting place if they’re not careful. A hilarious and often quite daring dark comedy that represents the absolute best of the genre, while also challenging the confines of what could be done on screen, The In-Laws is genuinely one of the funniest and most irreverent films of its era, and one that has aged better than nearly any satire produced at the time, which is far from an easy feat.

To fully understand the appeal of a film like The In-Laws, you need to situate it in the wider political and cultural context in which it was made, which is always an important step when looking at any satire made at a particular point in time. The Cold War was still at its peak, albeit in a bit of a transitional stage between eras, brought on by a new decade on the horizon. The United States had a stranglehold on much more than just its domestic situation, which meant that there were many countries in which they were involved, and very rarely for the most noble of reasons. In the case of this film, Bergman (a name some may not immediately recognise, but who was undeniably one of the most important comedy writers working at the time, having been behind screenplays for landmark films such as Blazing Saddles and The Freshman, the latter also being his directorial debut) had his eyes set on the subject of American interventionism, the belief that the country needed to act as a global watchdog, ensuring that democracy was able to spread without disruption, and eliminating all those who could pose a threat. For decades, the idea of the CIA being a shadowy organisation that does more harm than good has been a common literary cliché, even if its reputation can be massively inflated for the sake of either making audiences laugh or feeding into the evergreen conspiracy theories that tend to emerge whenever the subject arises, which is frankly far more frequently than anyone would have anticipated. When it comes to The In-Laws, it is obviously the former, with the premise revolving around a hopelessly inept agent who could not find his way out of a paper bag teaming up with a meek dentist to essentially save the global economy – all the while trying to get to know one another as future brothers-in-law, making this a very unconventional example of a bonding exercise, but not one without its own peculiar perks. We’re obviously not going to look to this film for the most elegant and detailed statement on the geopolitical landscape of the 1970s, but rather an intentionally more eccentric, off-the-wall version of these discussions, which it is more than willing to provide, particularly since it opens the possibility of making some remarkably astute statements in a more irreverent, and frankly effective, manner that reveals some very funny details lingering beneath the surface of the narrative.

As you would expect, the core thematic thread of The In-Laws is built from a few familiar tropes, and chief among them is the odd couple scenario. As we’ve seen on countless occasions, the idea of placing two diametrically opposed individuals in close proximity is one of the easiest and most reliable ways to create comedy, and that is almost entirely the foundation on which this film is constructed. A humble dentist being forced against his will to get involved with a morally corrupt CIA agent (who may or may not actually still be under the employment of the agency – that is part of the mystery that surrounds the film) is an immediately winning formula, and it is only helped by the exceptional casting decisions made when choosing the best actors to bring these roles to life. Few performers defined the decade more than Alan Arkin and Peter Falk, who reigned supreme as two of the most gifted actors to ever work in the medium – their ability to play everything from outrageous, broad comedy to tender drama is remarkable, and consolidated them as undeniable icons of the industry. The choice to hand them these roles seemed entirely logical, since not only do they both have ample experience with all the many different conceptual threads of the film (including both comedy and drama), they also tended to elevate even the most banal of moments, making them outrageously funny with seemingly very little work. Individually, they are hilarious, and pairing them together is simply divine, especially when so much of the film finds Falk playing into the irreverent trickster persona that he cultivated throughout his career, having him constantly getting on Arkin’s nerves, who is in turn at his most pernickety and uptight, leading to one hilarious scenario after another. Just to see these two incredible performers play off each other for nearly two hours is reason enough to seek out this film, and it’s only made richer and more engaging when we consider the extent to which they are both willing to go to entertain. There is not a single moment where either of them is not pushing the humour to the very limit, and it becomes part of the experience to see these remarkable actors working across from each other, doing whatever was required to honour the ambitious concept and bring it to the screen in as hilarious a way as possible. It remains some of the best work either actor ever did, and proves how chemistry is one of the most important parts of any casting process, since it can produce unforgettable results when done right.

While the film was conceived by Bergman (whose position as one of the most keen observers of social conventions to have ever worked in the medium is very clear through the many tremendous satires he wrote over the years) and is most notable for the brilliant performances by the leads, Hiller deserves just as much credit for how he brings the story to the screen. This is a very bold concept, and in the wrong hands it could’ve ended up being a needlessly overwrought jumble of ideas where the purpose is lost and replaced instead by a series of illogical moments that serve very little functional purpose. As one of the great journeyman filmmakers of his generation (back when the term wasn’t used to deride filmmakers who didn’t quite establish themselves as auteurs, but rather was just an objective description of a director who had a bit more versatility in their style), Hiller had a strong command of different aspects of the medium – and considering he had directed some tremendous comedies prior to this, we knew this subject was in the right hands, especially based on how much of it skirted along the edges of multiple genres. At its core, the film has two main threads: the comedy-of-errors and the political satire. They are evidently not mutually exclusive by any means, but they do come together brilliantly based on how Hiller draws fascinating correlations between them. The key to succeeding with a film like this has to do primarily with momentum – so much of the film relies on how much the audience is willing to be patient, as well as sitting with some very uncomfortable feelings, a result of the entire story being shrouded in a veneer of intentional awkwardness, where every scene becomes more hopelessly uncomfortable than the last, which then circles back to outrageously funny. It’s the kind of film whose humour is difficult to put down in words, since so much of it relies on the atmosphere – even reciting some of the dialogue doesn’t entirely encompass just how far the film is willing to go to get a laugh (for example, stating that the word “serpentine” has never been funnier than in this film means very little unless you’ve witnessed how it comes about), which is a credit not only to the fantastic writing, but also to the steadfast direction. Hiller brings a sense of order to a story that is defined by pure chaos, and the results are extraordinary, walking the line between comedy and thriller with a precision we’ve rarely seen come across as effectively as it does here.

There are some films that you simply cannot resist having a fun time with, since a strong story, entertaining characters and a very clear sense of direction can usually be a winning combination for any project, especially one as assured and captivating as this one. The In-Laws is a rambunctious and strange film that may be a bit rough around the edges and slightly thornier than it had any right to be, but this is all part of the charm, since no one involved was trying to make something that followed every convention, but instead functioned as something a bit more abstract and unconventional, while still maintaining the same general form that we would expect, both narratively and in terms of how these offbeat ideas are manifested on screen. It is often quite strange, but this is all part of the experience – it intends to take us on a wild ride, and it certainly wastes no expense in getting us there, every moment exuding the kind of chaotic energy that we often find to be excessive when handled by those who don’t know exactly what to do with these more abstract ideas. The In-Laws builds itself around two phenomenal performances – at a glance, we think Arkin and Falk are just playing into their usual personas (although that is not inherently a negative – many films have been constructed around their iconic traits), but as we explore the film further and come to peer beneath the surface, it becomes clearer that Hiller has achieved something truly remarkable here, a perfect blend of different comedic styles, all of which exist in near-perfect harmony with one another, coming together to form a brilliantly chaotic jumble of bold ideas and even more ambitious execution. It can frequently be quite absurd, but we’d expect nothing less from a film that is this remarkably bold in how it embraces the underlying humour in every situation. It sometimes takes its time to get to a particular point, but this is purposeful – if we’re not feeling as frustrated and confused as Sheldon, then the film isn’t achieving the intended effect. Masterfully crafted, brilliantly acted and never anything short of mystifyingly brilliant, The In-Laws is quite simply one of the best comedies of the decade, and a film that has aged remarkably well. Perfection is not something that is easy to achieve, and even with some flaws scattered here and there, this film comes remarkably close in ways that only delight and bewilder in equal measure.

Leave a Reply