The Diary of a Chambermaid (2026)

What unites Luis Buñuel and Radu Jude? It’s not only their shared affection for the absurd or their fascination with class and social structure that usually manifested in some of the most scathing and provocative works of cultural commentary, but also a love for a very particular novel, namely The Diary of a Chambermaid by Octave Mirbeau, which has been hailed as one of the great works of class-based literature and an unimpeachable classic that continues to cause quite a stir because of its provocative glimpse at the often unspoken rules of social and cultural etiquette that keep everyone in their place. Their shared appreciation for the material manifested in both directors seeking out opportunities to adapt it to film, with Jude’s recent endeavour to bring it to life on screen being the subject of our discussion today. The story is moved from the turn of the 20th century to the present day, taking place in Bordeaux, where we are introduced to Gianina, a young woman originally from Romania who has sought out opportunities outside her native country in an effort to support her daughter and mother, who live in a rural part of Moldavia, doing what she can to give them a better life, even if it means taking jobs that are decidedly not all that pleasant. However, she has been fortunate enough to be in the employment of the exceptionally wealthy Donnadieu family, who may prove that money can’t necessarily buy taste or class, but who still prove to be relatively decent people, treating her with respect, something that the young woman is certainly not used to after years of being viewed as invisible at best, a nuisance at worst. The film follows Gianina as she goes about her daily routine, patiently counting down the days to Christmas, which is when she will be returning to Romania for a short holiday, in which she can be reunited with her daughter, only to realise that even the kindest of employers can sometimes reveal themselves to have some quite severe flaws in certain situations. A fascinating character study that combines humour and pathos in a way that is quite unexpected but always intriguing, The Diary of a Chambermaid is quite an achievement, and an interesting change of pace for a filmmaker who has not made something this subtle and elegant in quite some time.

Stories built around the dynamics between the working-class and the bourgeoisie are so widespread in every conceivable medium that it borders on almost convoluted, since it is seemingly nearly impossible to explore this theme without touching on ideas that have already been extensively examined from every possible angle. It certainly doesn’t help when we are looking at a film that is based on a text written over a century ago, and has itself not only been the subject of numerous adaptations on both stage and screen, but also been the inspiration for many other works. However, anyone who believes that a filmmaker like Jude, who couldn’t be derivative if he tried, would surrender to the same thematic ideas, is certainly underestimating him. The Diary of a Chambermaid may seem like a traditional upstairs-downstairs narrative, in which a reserved young woman finds herself in service of a very wealthy family, their dynamic revealing that the person who is viewed lower on the socio-cultural ladder is covertly the most principled, and whose elegance may not manifest in beautiful possessions or widespread recognition, but rather in her ability to put in an honest day’s work, bettering both her life and that of the people she cares for, which outweighs any material wealth. This is the starting point, but certainly not the entire accumulation of all of Jude’s very ambitious ideas, since the film reveals itself to have far more layers than we would expect at a cursory glance. The fact that it centres around a woman who is an immigrant from an impoverished village in Romania immediately adds depth to the film, as well as a timeliness, allowing the director to work through some fascinating conversations around not only class, but also national identity. Gianina, as she is quick to observe, is from a European country and therefore has every right to find employment elsewhere in the continent – but yet she is constantly viewed as an outsider, someone who is lesser simply because of the reputation her country has across Europe, an unfair and often misguided set of beliefs that the film works to dismantle in its own small but significant way. Jude has not often been this forthright about exploring how Romanians are perceived outside their borders (although, to his credit, this is the first time he has made a film set elsewhere), which allows him to make what is unexpectedly one of his most subversive and provocative works to date.

Just under a decade ago, Jude made the decision to move away from more austere, dramatic works and started to explore surrealism as a form of artistic expression, leading to a run of films that redefined the medium and established him as one of the most daring and provocative names working in contemporary cinema. It has been so successful that he has not only pioneered a distinctive style all of his own, but also inspired filmmakers to adopt a similar style of their own, which is perhaps the most significant sign of someone’s artistic influence. It seems reasonable that we’d expect a film like The Diary of a Chambermaid to follow this approach, since it has seemingly become part and parcel of his own bespoke form of artistic expression. However, this film signals a momentary return to a kind of filmmaking he hasn’t engaged in for over a decade, since it is a far more subtle, dramatic affair – it certainly has its moments of irreverent humour, but they are more surprising, functioning as seasoning on a film that is much more of a drama than anything he’s made this decade. The reasons are not entirely clear at first, but it very likely has to do with the gravity of the themes being explored – it’s not the first time Jude has touched on some more serious subject matter, but it is one that demanded he set aside the wacky, off-the-wall tone and instead approach it from a more subtle perspective, which actually serves the film exceptionally well. His style is still very evident in the fabric of the film, which is still exceptionally subversive, but in a way that is far more calculated and sincere, where the madness takes place in the margins rather than right in front of us. It doesn’t mean that it’s a dour film – there’s plenty of moments where Jude embraces the inherent silliness of everyday life (the sub-plot of the protagonist appearing in an amateur production of Mirbeau’s novel, in addition to adding a meta layer to the film, are also exceptionally funny and deeply provocative), which then interact with the quieter, more sincere depictions of the domestic space, where Gianina tries to make a living while also attempting to not lose herself to the sense of hopelessness that begins to fester within her, the further she allows herself to be just another pawn in a game she never signed up to play.

When it comes to casting, there are essentially two qualities that Jude’s films tend to share: they either employ actors from his regular stable of actors (which seems to be steadily growing with every new film), or they focus on the art of discovering exciting new talents. The latter has always been one of the strongest aspects of the director’s work, since he has a remarkable ability to find performers who can capture the many nuances of his writing, while also collaborating with him on a much deeper and seemingly more profound level, making every one of his films intriguing in their own bespoke and daring way. The Diary of a Chambermaid centres around a character played by Ana Dumitrașcu, who has not previously worked with the director in a major role (she has a brief part in Dracula), but if her stellar performance in this film is anything to go by, we certainly have not seen the last of her. A young woman who has grown weary of the unbearable weight of the world, forced to lead a life in which she is constantly in service of those who are supposedly above her on the social ladder, and who therefore believe it is their right to exploit her, especially since she is such an outsider – whether as an abattoir worker in Spain or a maid in France, she will always be, first and foremost, a foreigner, someone whose services are useful but who no one wishes to consider as anything more than an employee. It’s a lonely life, and it is therefore important that the character reflects this sense of isolation. Dumitrașcu delivers such a stellar, captivating performance as Gianina, finding so much truth and complexity in a seemingly simple protagonist, bringing so much nuance and complexity to a part that would’ve otherwise felt too heavy-handed had someone without this sense of self-awareness and willingness to embrace the unhinged absurdity of modern existence. The cast is populated with other newcomers, such as mainstays in the French film industry such as Vincent Macaigne and Mélanie Thierry, as well as Jude regulars such as Ilinca Manolache, who steals every scene she is in, but where everything ultimately circles back to Dumitrașcu, whose stellar performance feels so much more compelling based on how willing she is to follow Jude’s lead as he tackles some very intimidating subject matter.

Those expecting Jude to have used Mirbeau’s timeless novel as the foundation for yet another of his wacky, off-the-wall surreal dark comedies are bound to be slightly disappointed, since The Diary of a Chambermaid is a surprisingly elegant and serious affair, but not any less engaging or provocative than his more daring works, which is why it is not difficult to embrace, even if he usually does his best work when he’s able to lean into the inherent absurdity of everyday life. It’s very complex storytelling that does take a bit of time to get used to, but if there is something we’ve learned through over a decade of Jude’s exceptional work, in which the borders of art are called into question in ways that are incredibly subversive and deeply unsettling, growing into something genuinely quite daring while also maintaining a kind of elegance that we don’t always anticipate from someone who has so gleefully set out to dismantle the boundaries of a medium that he both reveres and finds often quite inauthentic, particularly when addressing some more complex subjects that are not always entirely comfortable. It’s harrowing at times, and achingly beautiful at others – even setting aside the very intense socio-cultural commentary, the film is mainly a story of a young woman trying to make a better life for herself and her daughter, but who finds herself perpetually stuck in a loop, where she comes close to breaking free of these constraints, but inevitably ends up back right at the start, constantly seeking out a means to escape but gradually realising that some people are just born to be in service of one another. It’s not particularly easy to understand some of these references, and like many of his works, it requires the viewer to have some deeper understanding of Romanian culture that may not be possible for those of us born outside of that society to understand the full scope of what he is trying to say. However, The Diary of a Chambermaid is nevertheless a daring and compelling drama that quietly deconstructs sacred cultural institutions, finding fascinating ways to redefine the culture and ultimately revealing much more about society and the brutality of the class system than just about any other film released in the past year, which is in itself more than enough reason to celebrate Jude as nothing short of a complete and utter visionary.

Leave a Reply