Fatherland (2026)

There is a legitimate (and almost ironclad) argument that all art is political – it’s not a radical idea, and one that has been the source of constant discussion around the responsibility handed to artists to use their craft to tell stories that either contribute to the cultural conversation or move it forward in some way or another. However, I’ve often been drawn to those works which are certainly formed from some kind of political situation, but where the focus is not on the more conventional narrative approach, but rather on exploring the moments in between large events. Over the course of a career that has stretched back over thirty years, Paweł Pawlikowski has been very much focused on exploring the past in a manner that highlights some of its more unorthodox qualities – but yet he’d be the last to refer to himself as a particularly political filmmaker, despite some of his early work, which often presented complex portraits of regimes and political figures, being amongst the greatest pieces of non-fiction filmmaking of the era. His fascination with history and unique artistic approach has made him quite an enigmatic artist, and one who has continued to develop stories that capture certain elusive qualities that tend to be difficult to pin down precisely. It is in Fatherland (Polish: Ojczyzna) that we find some of his most provocative and compelling ideas, many of which align with those that he explored in Ida and Cold War, forming an unofficial trilogy of films that explore European history around the midpoint of the 20th century. Fatherland is set in 1949, and follows esteemed author Thomas Mann as he returns to Germany to accept the prestigious Goethe Prize, which entails being in attendance at ceremonies in both the democratic West Germany and the communist East Germany, which is not an easy position for someone who has been living as an exile in the United States for years. Accompanied by his daughter Erika, who acts as both his chauffeur and translator, the pair travel between different cities and villages, quietly observing the enormous changes that surround them, and realising that the country of their birth is perhaps not quite the place that they remember. Simple but effortlessly poignant, Fatherland is a fascinating glimpse into the mind of two people struggling to reconcile the past with the present, leading to a film that is as deeply provocative in its intentions as it is profoundly moving in execution.

Fatherland is fascinating for several different reasons, with one of the more distinct qualities being that it is Pawlikowski’s first narrative film to feature real historical figures as the centrepiece of the story, a departure from his usual approach to exploring the past through fictional characters in scenarios that may be steeped in reality, but are still constructions for the most part. This lends him the opportunity to craft a film with a bit more of a clear structure and a stronger historical foundation, which is evident in the fact that the screenplay was written in collaboration with Hendrik Handloegten, whose own Babylon Berlin remains one of the most powerful and detailed artistic depictions of 20th-century German history. However, as we have come to expect from his work, Pawlikowski is not solely interested in a by-the-numbers portrayal of the past – he is certainly fascinated enough by the subject matter to explore it extensively, but there is a restraint behind this film that underlines his true intentions, which is to examine the inner psychological architecture of this people, looking at what Thomas and Erika Mann both experienced upon their return to Germany, witnessing a continent that was changing in astonishing and often quite uncomfortable ways – and it all points towards something much more sombre and challenging, which is the unbearable weight of the past and how it can often challenge us in ways that we would not expect. That is ultimately the core of what makes Fatherland so intriguing – it takes someone like Thomas Mann, arguably one of the most important writers of his generation, and repositions him as an ordinary man, surrounded by people who place him on a pedestal, but who secretly just wants to find a place to call home, only realising upon his return that his Heimat no longer exists, at least not in the form that it took in his memories. The film is about two people who are ultimately living between worlds – both Thomas and Erika fled Germany during the rise of the Nazi regime, settling in the United States and Switzerland respectively, which offered them both physical and artistic sanctuary, but could never quite be called their home, especially since their real homeland constantly called out to them. This film explores the process of trying to return home and realising that it has taken on an entirely different form, the only traits that they recognise being in the small, seemingly inconsequential details that they begin to notice as they undergo this intimidating journey into the past.

As we would expect, Fatherland is a film that covers an intimidating amount of thematic ground, both in terms of the historical context (even when it doesn’t expand too deeply on certain ideas, they do still tend to linger in the ether, a purposeful choice on the part of the director) and the more intimate elements, which makes the film a slightly unorthodox blend of a biographical drama and a complex character study. Unsurprisingly, this intentional approach facilitates a pair of extraordinary performances, delivered by Sandra Hüller and Hanns Zischler, who are two of the most fascinating actors of their generation, and who are paired together in a film that represents some of their best work to date, which is truly saying something considering the staggering breadth of their respective careers. At a glance, we do expect Zischler to be the more prominent of the two, since the film is based around Thomas’ journey across Germany at the tail-end of the 1940s, where he witnessed the growing division of his homeland. The performance is filled to the brim with complexities that are not entirely revealed at first, but gradually compound as we make our way through the film. In many of the most memorable moments, he is communicating almost entirely through his expressions and gestures, the non-verbal cues telling a story of their own, and painting a portrait of a man attempting to process the thorny nature of the past without losing his grasp on reality. However, while she may seem to exist only on the periphery, acting as primarily the travelling companion for her father, Erika is just as fascinating a character, and we can even argue that she is the heart and soul of Fatherland – and I don’t think it’s out of line to suggest that most of this is a result of casting Sandra Hüller in the part. Very few actors have managed to immerse themselves in every role that they’ve played with such fervent commitment, but this is all part of what makes Hüller such an astonishing performer, someone who can play just about any role, which points to both her versatility and the fearlessness she has to tackle some very difficult subject matter. These are both performances that rely on body language as much as it does the dialogue (which is still exceptionally strong, and they both handle it brilliantly), and the genuine connection that the leads form create such a powerful and fascinating dynamic that pushes the film forward, making it a far more compelling endeavour than it could’ve been had Pawlikowski not found the perfect actors to interpret these complex and challenging roles.

Pawlikowski occupies that very elite company of directors who are able to make films that are both conceptually extremely strong and formally very dynamic, each one representing the perfect balance between these two vital elements, which ultimately leads to some incredibly captivating filmmaking that is both daring and deeply effective in delivering whatever message is situated at their core. They’re made even more remarkable based on their simplicity, with the director being adamant in his refusal to make films that are overly complicated or unnecessarily dense. Fatherland is yet another example of this in practice, taking the form of a very simple, humble historical drama that avoids all of the usual clichés and heavy-handed techniques often associated with the genre. Running at an astonishingly paltry 81 minutes (even less when we take into account the credits, and which proves to be a perfect example of why many directors who embrace the art of brevity in filmmaking), the film is quite a brief affair, which is part of its appeal – it is not intended to be a definitive examination of either of the two protagonists, but instead a quiet character study about a pair of people trying to understand the world that surrounds them, which they only begin to comprehend upon observing the small details that they would not have noticed had they not been so focused on finding meaning in surroundings that grow steadily more unfamiliar as they immerse themselves deeper into it as part of this metaphysical journey they are on. Fatherland could’ve so easily been an overly didactic, unnecessarily dense historical drama that lacks any real sense of cohesion, but Pawlikowski is much smarter than to just follow the traditions, instead pursuing something much more abstract, which proved to be the right approach. Filmed in gorgeous black-and-white (matching the previous two entries into this unofficial trilogy), the film takes the form of a mood poem, being driven primarily by atmosphere more than anything else – the plot (while very strong) exists only to get these characters from one point to another, with the most meaningful elements being found in the intricate details, which encourage the viewer to pay close attention to the surroundings, since there are aspects that initially may go unnoticed, but which add so much texture to an already incredibly layered film. The stoic, forthright tone only emphasises the deeply moving commentary at the heart of the film, with everything coming together to form this beautifully poetic journey into the past.

It certainly is difficult not to fall under the spell of Fatherland, a film so exquisitely crafted, but which also thrives as a result of its simplicity, proving that it is entirely possible to create something both stylish and meaningful through the right combination of a good concept and a dedicated execution of those ideas. We can’t be surprised, since Pawlikowski is always someone who takes his time to develop his films as complex, intricately woven glimpses into the human condition, and even at its most unfurnished, there is a nuance to this film that anchors everything and makes it so incredibly compelling. Whether we are drawn to the film’s deep exploration of history, particularly the conversation between characters (since this is the primary vessel used by the film to expand on the specific details of the period in which the story takes place), or the astonishing central performances that anchor the film, or even just the gorgeous imagery that envelopes the film, adding to the atmospheric approach of the narrative, there is something to draw every viewer in, especially since it is such a brief film that no one should feel like it is overstaying its welcome. It all ultimately works towards the creation of a captivating and deeply moving parable about two people who are initially portrayed as a world-renowned author and an acclaimed actress journeying between cities on their way to accept a prize, but who eventually evolve into being seen as something far simpler: a father and his daughter, accompanying each other on a complex voyage into the past, doing whatever they can to process some difficult emotions that emerge when realising their surroundings are no longer the same as they were in their memories, which is a disorienting and deeply melancholic experience that may resonate with viewers in unexpected ways, which may surprise those of us who were expecting a more conventional historical drama, rather than a poignant character study about the challenges that come with processing difficult memories. A complex and deeply moving character study handcrafted by a filmmaker whose curiosity about the past has resulted in yet another stellar achievement, Fatherland is an exceptional film that understands not only the weight of history, but also the importance of moving forward, which it communicates without being too overwrought or didactic, finding the right combination of tone, style and story, and proving to be an absolutely extraordinary achievement. A fascinating and engrossing addition to his already stellar body of work, this film proves that Pawlikowski remains one of our most interesting contemporary filmmakers, and someone whose ability to challenge and move the audience remains unprecedented; this being amongst his best works.

Leave a Reply