
Roughly fifty years ago, a down-on-his-luck young man stepped into the office of a pair of Hollywood producers, armed with nothing but a screenplay he had written in a few days, and a dream large enough to fuel a country’s entire population. History was made, and the results speak for themselves, since it’s difficult to argue with success when it is presented so directly. This is obviously a reference to Sylvester Stallone, whose journey to make Rocky is one of the most beloved stories in the history of cinema, particularly since it was not only the moment he skyrocketed to worldwide fame, but essentially changed the industry in a small but significant way. I am certainly not a major devotee of Rocky (which is more to do with my general ambivalence to this particular brand of motivational sports drama – I find them to be dull at the best of times, tacky at the worst), but anyone who has even pondered the history of the medium will be aware of what a major achievement it was to bring that story to the screen. It took half a century, but now the story of the production of the film has finally been made, in the form of I Play Rocky, directed by Peter Farrelly and based on a screenplay by Peter Gamble, which dramatises Stallone’s early career as a struggling actor who had to take a range of bit parts in mainstream films and leading roles in softcore pornography merely as a means to survive, every cent he earned allowing him to evade being forced to live on the streets. The film chronicles the challenges he faced bringing Rocky to life, specifically since he was adamant that he should play the titular role, despite everyone around him believing that the only shot he had of getting his passion project made was to sell his screenplay and allow the role to be played by some established star, something that did not align with his own ambitions. A film that is about as obvious as it is shallow, I Play Rocky is nothing special, a relatively derivative biographical drama that does very little we’ve not seen already, and doesn’t do much in favour of revealing new insights into a story that has been retold dozens of times, just not in as direct a way as we see here.
To understand I Play Rocky and its reasons for being made, we have to ask one very simple question: what is it that draws people to Rocky, or any similarly themed film? The answer is that we are predisposed to loving underdog stories, and the story of a scrappy young boxer who sees the chance at fame, defying all resistance and overcoming every obstacle that stands in his way, is undeniably compelling, to the point where even those who aren’t particularly enamoured with those films can still see why they would appeal to a large portion of the audience. These ideas are even more notable when we consider that the journey to get Rocky to the screen was as arduous and difficult a process as the protagonist’s own efforts to become a world-renowned boxer, with the unexpected parallels being the foundation of this project, and ultimately the reason it both succeeds at accomplishing a set of very clear goals, and eventually struggles to say much more than this by the end. There is still inherent value in I Play Rocky, which is primarily in how it offers a behind-the-scenes look at the film industry at a very particular point in time – when Rocky went into production, the era of New Hollywood was at its peak, with several actors being anointed as major stars, and the industry as a whole was undergoing several changes, which left the door open for several very gifted young artists to feel motivated to stake their claim in a rapidly shifting vocation. The best parts of this film are those in which we see the various tricks and techniques employed by both NAME and NAME, who served as the producers and acted as the curators of this ambitious idea, as well as director John G. Avildsen, whose own gonzo sensibility and devil-may-care attitude made him a very unique filmmaker at the time. It’s almost as if the least interesting aspect of this film is the person who is pushed to the front, since despite the men tasked with realising his screenplay being far more intriguing, the idea of watching a group of producers bickering amongst themselves, while undeniably entertaining and insightful, does very little in terms of adhering to the underdog narrative that Farrelly was so desperately trying to harness throughout this film.
The problem with this film is less to do with how the ideas are brought to life – Farrelly is a competent director (which is about as much praise as I can layer on him, since he’s not really ever shown himself to be particularly gifted behind the camera), and he does what was required to bring this story to the screen. The issue is mainly based around the fact that this is an underdog story where there isn’t an ounce of tension, and the viewer is not kept in suspense in any way, even when the film tries to manufacture it, which backfires tremendously. Unless someone is completely oblivious to the Rocky films (or any mainstream sports-based film as a whole), there is not going to be any mystique to this film, despite its best efforts to create a tense atmosphere. These are people who we know, from the very beginning, set out to make a film that was intended to be a low-budget vanity project for a man who would go on to become one of the greatest movie stars of his generation, working alongside a group of people whose fervent belief in his vision allowed them to win many awards, cementing their place in history. It’s a lovely story, but one that simply did not need to be turned into an entire film, especially when there is nothing to keep us invested. It’s blatantly obvious that this is a film written by someone without much experience (Gamble has a few credits, but nothing of consequence so far), with the abundance of cliches and lack of narrative stakes being noticeable from the start, to the point where the film has to rely on some very heavy-handed tricks to keep us interested, which often leads to either misplaced humour, or an over-indulgence in the kind of low-stakes emotional pandering that would be manipulative if it wasn’t so completely obvious, but we shouldn’t expect anything less from a director like Farrelly, who has seemingly never been able to embrace subtlety for a single moment in his professional career, with I Play Rocky just being yet another mediocre entry into his already bland body of work from the past decade.
There has been a lot discussed about the decision to cast Anthony Ippolito as Stallone, which is probably the most publicised aspect of this film as a whole. It’s quite obvious when someone was cast purely based on how closely they look like the person that they are playing, since he has not done all that much work (at least not enough to justify leading such a film), but the fact that he looks eerily close to Stallone is undeniable, leading us to wonder if the entire purpose of this film’s existence was as a means to get him to play him, rather than anything to do with the actual story being worth telling. To be fair, it is difficult to imagine any established actor playing the role, purely because Stallone is so distinctive in every way that it seemed like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to throw Ippolito into the part, regardless of his talent. Mercifully, he does have a fair amount of screen presence and seems to be a decent enough actor (and it is very amusing that he also had a major role in The Offer, another behind-the-scenes look at the creation of an even more popular 1970s film, where he played Al Pacino during the production of The Godfather), which at least removes one potential obstacle that this film had to clear. However, the more we immerse ourselves in this film, the clearer it becomes that a close physical resemblance and the ability to do a passable (but hardly spectacular) vocal impression do not make for an immediately compelling performance, and it often feels as if we are watching a promising young actor be shoehorned into a part merely because he possessed the physical attributes to play someone who is the very definition of a true original. Nevertheless, Ippolito does his best, and despite the characterisation of Stallone leaving a lot to be desired (since turning him into a slightly immature man-child whose stubbornness is supposed to be endearing and admirable is far from ideal), he is decent enough to catch our attention – unfortunately, the film is not good enough to hold it, which becomes one of its many questionable aspects.
A bundle of poorly constructed moments based around the production of an iconic film that are supposed to tug at the heartstrings but inspire nothing but apathy is certainly not the way to tell such a story, and when the only genuine response you can get from the audience is that they would prefer to go home and watch the original Rocky (an even more impressive achievement if referring to those of us who don’t particularly subscribe to the legendary status of that film), we have a pretty severe cause for concern. It’s not a catastrophe – it’s actually not nearly interesting enough to be even vaguely disastrous, which is a fair trade-off for a film that was aiming for the low-hanging fruit, and only marginally succeeds in keeping us engaged and invested. The exact audience for this film isn’t clear – it’s mostly going to play to those who are sentimental about Rocky (as if the film, or the many works that it inspired, are now suddenly going to disappear from existence, becoming out of reach), or the people who enjoy these mid-level biographical films that rely on a combination of humour and melodrama to tell the most obvious story imaginable. What is obvious is that any filmmaker banking on nostalgia as the primary currency for a film like this is not to be taken seriously, especially when the results are this bland and uninteresting. The lack of stakes or even an ounce of tension makes I Play Rocky a bit of a chore to get through (and at over two hours in length, it certainly overstays its welcome, especially when the main point the film was built around was made within the first thirty minutes), feeling like a squandered opportunity to explore themes such as masculinity, culture and the unbearable weight of trying to achieve something that seems impossible. This film proves that even the most compelling of subjects can be rendered almost entirely inconsequential when given the wrong approach, which is entirely definitive of this bland, uninspired biographical drama that never amounts to anything more than pure mediocrity.